Every Thursday morning I take the corner seat at Bu Marni’s warung, a roadside stall where black coffee comes with no promise beyond being hot. My glass is barely half drunk when the next table starts stirring an old quarrel: the diploma, the spectacles and the moustache. At home, the three are mere household furnishings. Here, they have been promoted to exhibits.The table on the left belongs to the fritter-fryers. Fritters here never get the chance to go cold, and rumours are handled in much the same way. One gentleman is certain the photograph on the diploma is not its owner, since students of that era, he says, never graduated in glasses. The young man beside him retorts that spectacles were invented long before the republic existed. A third, who once photographed a wedding, feels he understands light. One plate of fried tempeh, three instant professorships.The sugar sits in the middle of the table, and everyone spoons it to taste. That is how opinion works: one spoonful makes the coffee sweet for the sweet-toothed and bitter for those who refuse it, though the glass holds the same thing.Coffee itself is a simple matter: grounds, hot water, patience. Proving a document ought to be as plain: show the papers, hand them to an examiner who takes no side, publish the result. Yet the owner of the disputed glass treats it like a family heirloom: kept in a cupboard, locked, brought out on an auspicious day, and even then to be admired from a safe distance. Anyone wishing to taste is invited to queue at the police station.The doubters order only what any stall would offer: open testing by an institution that depends on nobody. A citizen asking about a public figure’s document is exercising a right, not planning a crime. They point out that copies from two agencies are said to differ from one another, and that the original was shown only after the case had rolled on for a long time. Those are their side’s claims, unverified, but the question is fair: show it, test it, done. Many outside this stall judge them to have been criminalised for asking, and at the back table a suspicion circulates that the law moves faster when the glass owner’s pockets are deep. That suspicion is unverified and the court has ruled on nothing, yet the impression is plain: asking now looks risky, while answering looks expensive.The holder of the glass gets the thickest grounds. A person whose glass has been doubted for years needs no special talent to end the doubt; one placement on the table of a laboratory both camps agree upon will do. Waiting for years, then showing it to a courtroom gallery, is like a conjurer pulling the last cloth after the audience has gone home: the rabbit may be genuine, but the applause is late.Spectators who fan the embers deserve a nudge as well. Some turn the quarrel into a pulpit, some into campaign material, some into breathless headlines. The genuine drinkers, who only wanted to know whether their glass was clean, are left with the grounds.The moustache, by the governance of this stall, counts as an urgent matter. One opinion calls it thin, another calls it bushy, and a photograph decades old is drafted in as referee. I heard from the back table that a celebrity deliberately grew one to match an old photograph. I found no reporting confirming it, so it goes on the unverified-rumour shelf.The last fritter on the plate is a matter of policy. Prosecuting the questioner is a route the statute book provides, but it turns a question into a case and makes citizens think twice before asking anyone in power. The issuing institutions, too, speak more often through press releases than through archives anyone can inspect, though an archive is a witness that needs no lawyer.As for the police laboratory test, the doubters consider the investigators not independent and ask for another institution, while the glass owner objected when a retest was requested in court, arguing the police lab had already tested. The police themselves said last week that no new test was needed. A notion also circulates that the owner was once close to the institution’s helmsman; it is unverified, and the helmsman did change on 1 October 2026. The ship has a new captain, but the same chart. So the case stalls at a crossroads: one side distrusts the old result, the other refuses a new one, and whenever another examiner is named, the door is politely shut. If the closeness is mere prejudice, refuting it is easy and free: hand the glass to an examiner nobody can accuse of befriending anyone.In fairness, I note the other side once: the holder of the glass is entitled to use legal channels, the police say the document was tested procedurally, and no final and binding judgment exists, so doubt has not automatically become truth. If the glass is genuine, an open test costs one afternoon; if not, it costs more. The stall can only guess from how the glass is guarded, and guessing is not proof.My recipe is plain. First, an independent forensic examination: the method published, experts from both camps, the raw data open to public inspection. Second, the issuing and archiving institutions releasing certified copies and explaining any difference between copies, if there truly is one. Third, public figures making a habit of early openness, since candour at the start is cheaper than a late clarification. Fourth, critics submitting their calculations to peer review before the timeline.From the clapped-out radio perched on the glass cabinet comes the tune Bu Marni insists on every morning: Cheap Thrills. Only now do I understand her choice. Cheap sensations sell briskly at this stall: a plate of tempeh, street-side fritters, and a fresh coconut on ice, all affordable and quickly gone. Nobody goes hungry, yet many leave full of fritters and still full of questions. There is nothing wrong with cheap pleasures; what costs more is clarity, and its price is a single afternoon, one examiner nobody can accuse of taking sides, and everyone’s willingness to accept the result. Until that bill is paid, the radio will keep playing the same song.My glass is down to a finger’s width. The fritters are gone, the next table is still arguing. At the bottom, the dregs settle slowly. They ask neither to be proved nor to be shaved; they merely sink once nobody stirs them again. I pay three thousand rupiah and walk home with a head clearer than the coffee. Faintly, Sia sings that a party needs no money while the feet can still move: "I don't need no money, as long as I keep dancing ..."
Bahasa



