Notes on rhinos, tsunamis and the suspicion that comes with the order
On Wednesday morning I sat down at my regular warung at the corner of the lane, with a cup of black coffee whose grounds were still swirling before they finally settled. At the next table, three men were stirring their sugar with the zeal of people weighing the fate of the nation. Their topic was the same as half the internet's today: the Javan rhino may be moving house.
As far as I can tell, the story runs like this. On Thursday, 12 November, at a media briefing during COP31, the President's Special Envoy for Climate and Energy warned that every Javan rhino lives in a single place, Ujung Kulon, close to Mount Anak Krakatau. One tsunami, he said in essence, could wipe out an entire species at a stroke. Hence the proposal for a second home in Alas Purwo National Park, in Banyuwangi. The Indonesian Rhino Foundation recorded, as of 22 September 2026, only 80 to 100 animals remaining. With numbers that slender, putting every egg in one basket is indeed risky. The argument is as sweet as the first spoonful of sugar, and I admit it without embarrassment.
But coffee seldom stops at sweetness. Pak Darto, a retired biology teacher sitting beside the fan, cited WALHI, Indonesia's largest environmental network: the Javan rhino survived the eruption of Krakatoa in 1883, and Alas Purwo is drier than the muddy swamps the rhino favours. A Baduy elder in Lebak has likewise asked the government to think again. The Ministry of Forestry itself concedes that Alas Purwo is merely a candidate worth studying, not a decision, and on 17 November the Government Communication Agency promised that nothing would be rushed. So far, my cup was still pleasant to drink.
Lessons from smaller moves already exist. Last year the Ministry of Forestry shifted rhinos from Ujung Kulon to the Javan Rhino Study and Conservation Area, and according to reports in late November 2025, one of them died of illness. Pak Darto called it a reminder that a rhino is not a refill water jug to be carried from one warung to another. Moving animals within a national park carries risk; crossing nearly the whole length of Java is another matter.
Something else made the next table louder still: the vocabulary keeps changing. At one moment it is a notion, at another a plan; today a second habitat, tomorrow relocation, the day after translocation. Like a menu whose dishes keep being renamed, the customer is unsure what he is ordering. Clarity of terms is not a matter of grammar but of what is actually being decided, and when.
At the other end of the island, the would-be neighbours also have a say. Reportedly some residents of Banyuwangi object to the rhinos' arrival; I read this in a single headline and have not checked it further. Such objections cannot be treated as grounds to be tipped away, for new neighbours who were never consulted will be hard to persuade to share their forest. Chewing on a fritter, I mused that moving a rhino turns out to be easier than moving the feelings of the people around it.
The grounds only appeared when a young man in a ride-hailing jacket mentioned gold. WALHI suspects the plan is tied to gold-mining interests; the Ministry denies it. All I can confirm from the reporting is this: the Cibaliung mine, run by a subsidiary of Antam, does border the eastern tip of the national park. As for any causal link between that mine and the relocation idea, I have found no evidence. Greenpeace warns that if the rhinos leave, extractive industry could find it easier to creep into the Ujung Kulon landscape; that is a concern, not a finding. It remains an allegation. Grounds are always visible at the bottom of the glass, but they do not necessarily decide the taste.
Even so, the people of the warung are not entirely wrong to sniff around. An idea this large was announced first at an international climate forum, while its scientific study is still queuing in the kitchen. According to media reports, the cost is to be met through a conservation financing scheme offered to investors; I have not checked the official documents. It feels like selling coffee before the beans have been roasted. It is natural that anyone catching the aroma should ask who owns the new café.
Yet the sniffers, too, should sip honestly. The woman frying snacks, who had been listening quietly while turning her tempeh, remarked gently that the 2018 Sunda Strait tsunami was no fairy tale. She is right. The threat of eruptions and waves around Anak Krakatau is real, and suspicion without documents, however tempting, is like tipping the grounds onto the plate before the coffee is gone. Accusing is easy, like frying bananas: quickly cooked, quickly gone.
Besides, nobody in this warung wants the rhino to vanish, and there is no obligation to choose between the sugar and the grounds. A middle path can be designed. First, an open, independent study: rhino specialists, universities and indigenous communities at one table, with data on forage, water, wallows and habitat size published so anyone can test it. Second, treat the second habitat as an addition, not a replacement: begin with small, staged trials while patrols in Ujung Kulon are strengthened, as the government itself has promised. Third, publish the zoning maps and mining permits around the national park, and lock them, so that even if the rhinos move, no one can stroll in behind them. Fourth, audit conservation money in public, down to the last rupiah. That way suspicion runs out of fuel, and a good idea can proceed without prejudice trailing behind it.
My coffee has gone cold. I sip slowly and stop before the grounds. They stay at the bottom of the glass, neither thrown away nor stirred up again, because that is how coffee keeps its clarity: the thick settles, the clear rises, and each knows its place. May the rhino business turn out the same.
From the warung's wheezy speaker, set going by someone unknown, came Dirty Paws by Of Monsters and Men. The song is a fairy tale about animals: it opens softly, then slowly swells with handclaps and choral voices, as if the whole forest were singing along. I smiled, because the rhino business is, at heart, a tale we are writing together, whether it ends as a fable about the courage to save a home or as a story about a home quietly changing occupants. The difference is that the song's tale has already been written, whereas ours is still open, and everyone in this warung holds a share of the pen, through study, oversight, or simply a question that refuses to stop being asked. May the next chapter be written with a cool head and bright data, so that when our grandchildren hear a song like this, they can still see a real rhino in the rainforest, not only in the story.